About Us

We are an independent insurance agency that offers all lines of property and casualty insurance products, including but not limited to: home, auto, business, and farm.  We also offer life and disability insurance.

As an independent agent, we represent multiple companies. This gives us the ability to better serve the individual needs of our customers and we pride ourselves on the personal service that we offer.
We have been in business as a family owned company since 1977, serving Elkhart County and surrounding areas in Indiana and Michigan.



Ben is the owner and agent of Bill Evans Insurance, which was started by his grandfather in 1977. Ben has been with the company for 24 years and writes policies for farm, commercial, life, home, and auto.  He is also a notary public.  He is married to Jodi and they have three daughters.  In his spare time, he loves to farm and help his daughters with their 4-H animals.


Jodi worked for Bill Evans Insurance 14 years ago and left to be a stay-at-home mom.  She has been back with the agency since 2011.  She writes home, auto and farm policies and also does the agency’s bookkeeping.  She is married to Ben and loves spending time with their three daughters.  She enjoys farming, reading, 4-H, and watching her daughters play soccer.


Cati has been with Bill Evans Insurance since 2012 as the Customer Service Representative.  She is the mom of one with another on the way.  She loves spending time outdoors with her family. She also loves to swim, fish and enjoys movies.


“Working with the Bill Evans team has been a breeze. They knew exactly how to help me in my unusual situation. I can’t recommend them highly enough.”

John Rector